Listen to this article
In the last few months, five million Americans have become first-time gun buyers. That isn't because some Netflix special sparked a nationwide craze for deer hunting or trap shooting. This trend is being fueled by one overriding concern, protection.
Many kinds of guns will do the job of keeping you and your family safe. If you don't have any neighbors within a half-mile or so, an AR-15 could be the right choice for you. It is hard to beat. As an all-round protection piece, I'll swear by a good pump-action shotgun. If you hit someone with the right defense load, they are going down, no question. Whatever the arguments, most first-time gun buyers are looking for protection on the go, something handy and compact, and that means paying a little visit to pistol country.

Photo by Karolina Grabowska
Pistols are concealable, easy to carry, and easy to store, but they require the most training of any type of gun. If you don't practice regularly, you might as well be waving a banana at your assailant, let me get that out of the way right off the bat. Obviously, not all handguns are the same, and you'll have to practice the manual of arms for your specific piece. There are revolvers and semi-autos, single-action and double-action guns, hammer-fired and striker-fired, steel and polymer, the list of options goes on and on.
So what is the best handgun for protection for the first time buyer? First, let's rule out itty-bitty purse guns. The barrels are short, making them harder to shoot accurately. They are light, making the recoil harder to control, meaning follow-up shots are harder to place. We've cobbled together a list of five of the most common and proven full-sized handguns. Getting comfortable using any one of these is a valuable skill, as you'll run across them in every corner of the country. There's a reason for that, they have shown that they will do the job and do it reliably.
Colt 1911
This is the handgun your granddaddy carried across the beaches of Normandy. For many shooters, there is nothing quite so American as a Colt .45. This is a classic, ingenious design from the da Vinci of firearms, John Moses Browning. The .45 ACP round is a big honking projectile with more than enough stopping power. Colt isn’t the company that it used to be and today dozens of companies offer 1911s. Whether you get your 1911 from a high-end maker like Kimber, Wilson Combat, or some more affordable brand like Rock Island, it will definitely do the job and look the part. Detractors will cite a 500-round 'break-in period' as being a bit ludicrous and claim the design is outdated, but fanboys wouldn't trade in their Colt 45s for all the world.
Beretta 92
Let's just run through the succession of standard-issue NATO side-arms. There's a reason these bad boys get chosen by military procurement, but keep in mind, part of that is logistics and affordability. Hailing from the mid-70s, the Beretta 96 is another big honking fistful of steel. A million 1911 fanboys' hearts broke when it replaced their beloved piece, mainly because of the huge step down in caliber, from .45 to 9mm. Hey, smaller rounds mean it's easier to carry more firepower and raise your mag capacity. We're going from 7 or 8 rounds in the Colt, hardly more than a revolver, to around 17 in one Beretta mag. Keep in mind though, that your legal mag capacity will be restricted in some states, and most civilian kerfluffles involving guns get resolved with two shots max. These are iconic weapons. The exposed barrel helps with cooling, but the trigger pull can be long and sloppy. There are always aftermarket mods for that kind of thing. Fun fact, Beretta is one of the oldest companies in the world, founded in 1526.
Sig Sauer P226
Here's another no-nonsense semi-auto that has been in widespread use by the US military and many domestic police forces. It offers all the argument-ending quality and design finesse you'd expect of a German-Swiss collaboration. Like most modern semi-autos, it's offered in a few calibers, and mag capacity will depend on your choice. Upgrade from the Beretta above's default 9mm to a P226 in .40 S&W for a capacity somewhere in the mid-teens. The operation, trigger pull, and overall function are an obvious step above the Sig's forebearers. This is one of those can't-go-wrong options.
Glock G19
It's hard to talk about semi-auto pistols without mentioning Glock. Glocks are the Toyota Corollas of the handgun world. They are foreign, almost annoyingly reliable, and have all the character of grandma's refrigerator (minus the kitten magnets). More police forces use these guns than any other because they can take a severe beating and shake it right off. The 19 comes in 9mm with a pretty average 15-round mag capacity. One of the most significant differences between it and the models above is that it is mostly made of a hardy polymer, greatly reducing its weight. Another major difference is the way the safety is integrated into the trigger, making it simpler to operate. When it comes time for repairs or upgrades, you'll appreciate how interchangeable Glock components are.
Smith & Wesson 686
While many shooters say 'never go full revolver,' my philosophy with handguns is, 'always go .357 Magnum.' That means buying a one-way ticket to revolver town. Revolvers are generally more reliable and simpler to operate than semi-autos. If you pull the trigger and nothing happens, pull it again, and something probably will. Not so with a semi-auto, have fun unjamming it while you're getting shot at. Many revolvers have a long, hard trigger pull, but they also have an exposed hammer that you can cock to make the trigger short and crisp. There is no safety, slide stop, takedown lever, or whatever other confusing bells and whistles they cram into semi-autos. Instead of extra mags, you carry speedloaders or moon clips. Sure, the revolver is bulkier, but it's curves can fit against the human figure and look more organic than an angular semi-auto. The Smith & Wesson 686 is the most obvious, ubiquitous choice, but there are other great options in .357 from Ruger and Kimber. One great feature is the ability to shoot .38 Special in a .357 gun whenever you don't need the full wallop. Just don't put your fingers in line with the forcing cone when firing.
Wrapping up
So there you have it. Choosing the best handgun is a highly personal decision. Big tough guys fuss as much over the minute details of their handgun choices as teenage girls fuss over their mascara. They get even more butthurt when their choice gets disparaged. Welcome to the firearms community! You can't really go wrong with any well-established handgun. It comes down to a matter of taste. Do your research and remember that affordability and availability are about as important as performance. Have fun, stay safe, and take your new piece to the range as often as you can.